From technology to politics to video games; these are the random thoughts of a geek with too much time on his hands

US Attorney General Alberto Gonzales went before Congress this week to urge senators to pass legislation that would require Internet Service Providers to retain logs of customers online activity for at least a year or two for use in police or federal investigations.  This lobbying comes amidst the most recent push to regulate online content, specifically that which is considered unsafe for minors.

The proposed data retention rules are strongly supported by law enforcement officials at more or less every level, starting as low as local sheriffs and going all the way to 49 attorneys general.  Privacy groups are expected to have a tough time gathering support to oppose any such laws.

Recent months have seen an increased interest in protecting minors online, with lawmakers turning their eyes to social networking sites like MySpace, Xanga and Facebook.  Additionally, data retention and analysis regulations are being considered for any organization that receives federal funding, specifically targeted at schools.

Currently, ISPs and other data connectivity providers are only required to retain data for up to 90 days, beyond which they can be deleted.  Specifics on how such records should be stored for the proposed 1-2 year period are not yet clear, and will likely pose a significant technological challenge to any service provider or social networking site required to comply.


Comments (Page 3)
3 Pages1 2 3 
on Sep 21, 2006

Various countries around the world have 'voyeuristic' shows on prime time television...in the guise of 'entertainment'.  Yes, obviously 'Big Brother' is one, but so too is 'Survivor' and all its spin-offs/copies.

People will [or appear to ] lap up this crud in buckets-full yet a few will balk at its introduction into their reality.

Start by being outraged at the concept of it as entertainment...and you might be just vaguely credible as a dissenter to its 'legal' introduction.

People shouldn't be worrying about the new 'laws'....only about who/what they have as a legal system.

It is not the overseeing that is a problem, but only the cock-ups/stupidity/naivete of those charged with its function....

on Sep 21, 2006
in a lot of cases you dont have to do anything wrong to get in trouble..
on Sep 22, 2006
....then it'll quietly happen anyway....



America is so apathetic. We get all wound up about something, then soon we forget about it, like sheep, and fix on the next "shiny object". Like fish...or monkeys... "Hey! The kid's crying! Just give him a rattle and he'll forget all about it." I'm not gonna go quietly. No sirree. Kicking and screaming all the way. Too bad they can't just spray for terrorists and pedophiles, like bugs. I'm p____d off, sorry


'fascism - evil overlord' hysteric analogy...



yeah, well... "hysteric"?...more like "berserker". Got a real case of the f___its today, that's all
I mean no disrespect
on Sep 22, 2006
Tear up the Constitution and throw it away!!! It's already so out of whack it couldn't be straightened out. We are not free and do not have rights anymore!!! The MIAA, The Patriot Act, ETC.... are all about trying to make this country go to shit!!! We have had our heads up our own asses and will continue to do so... It's not about what's right it's about power and control and of course MONEY!!! And there is no need to fear that we as Americans have totally F***ed up!!! The fact is everyday that many people are falsely accused of crimes they truthfully did NOT commit. Yet they are condemned by society, guilty before trial and after, yet the innocence is supposed to be there. I can safely say that if George Washington and the founding fathers of our country were to "come alive today" they would once again revolt and reword the constitution more appropriately so that the f***ing morons could never ammend it to fit personal agendas that are to "protect"!!! They used to say "America love it or leave it", I say gimme the money and I would leave the planet and not just America!! Shame to all of us for allowing this horrible SHIT to ever get started and now that the ball is rolling where is Indiana Jones to outrun it?

"You have nothing to fear, except the government itself!"

Speedy

P.S. Sorry if anyone finds this offensive. I find our society offensive and our government also and the latter is worse!!
on Sep 22, 2006
on Sep 22, 2006
America is so apathetic.


A large portion of America is apathetic, but there are those of us who do care about certain things and don't just give up on it. You also have to realize why we're apathetic.

Take the Iraq War for example. The war was designed to affect the least amount of people possible, otherwise it would never have happened. In the beginning, they said it would be relatively cheap and relatively quick. Rather than raise taxes for everyone, like has been done for all other wars, taxes were lowered (at least for the rich). Most of all, there is no draft. That is why there isn't the extreme outrage, particularly with us students.

Whether it be through ways to distance the public from the governments actions, or to disguise their illegal and immoral plans under 'national security,' America is apathetic not because we don't care, but because we've been given no reason to care. Personally, I still find that unacceptable, but people have a lot to think and worry about these days (at least they think they do), and a war or ISP record keeping is just another thing to add to the burden.
on Sep 22, 2006
Thanks, Adamness. I realize people care. I just get really frustrated now and then when there's a problem and I can't fix it or really do much about it. You've made some really good points. Rational and incisive. Thanks.
on Sep 22, 2006
So, why is the U.S. Government stepping in where parents of said children should be responsible? What kind of parent would let their small/young/potential victim of a child use a computer without privacy/parental control software (properly configured). The governement is not responsible for the safety of your children, YOU ARE. I personally view this as a form of invasion of privacy. Sounds like another way for parents to take even less of a part in raising their child to adulthood.
on Sep 22, 2006
A copule of points.

First, for the "if you're not doing anything wrong, what does it matter?" crowd: You're right, I'm not doing anything wrong. However, if some politico decides somewhere down the line to change the legal definition of "wrong" (which, it seems, is happening with more and more frequency), my present, quite legal behavior might get me, you, or all of us arrested. If it sounds like I'm being outlandish, wait a couple more years -- I can nearly guarantee that this will happen somewhere. Eventually, simply criticizing the government -- something I do daily, online and off -- is going to be illegal, and I guess I'll be seeing a lot of my fellow dissenters in prison.

Second, I'm pro-privacy, not because I have any nasty little secrets to hide (my life would be much more interesting if I did), but because there's business of mine that The Gummint does not need to know. If I elect to tell my girlfriend that I love her in email, does the miilitary/intelligence complex really need to know that? None of their g@%-d^*% business.
on Sep 22, 2006

If I elect to tell my girlfriend that I love her in email, does the miilitary/intelligence complex really need to know that? None of their g@%-d^*% business

Don't do it via Gmail then....

on Sep 24, 2006
~
Keep the data longer.
That way there is more chance of it being hacked
and falling into the wrong hands.
~
on Oct 25, 2006
Beware of Big Brother telling you that "they are doing it to protect our kids".
That's just an excuse to take our rights away.
And the coming Police State marches on!!
3 Pages1 2 3