From technology to politics to video games; these are the random thoughts of a geek with too much time on his hands
Published on April 29, 2008 By Zoomba In Internet

As you've probably already noticed, we put out an update to the central Stardock Forum system today that comes packed with fixes, plus a handful of very useful new features.  Instead of letting you guess randomly at what's new and how it works, I thought I'd give everyone a quick run-down of the new features.

  1. Forum Announcements
  2. Return of the Report Button
  3. Go to Top of Thread Button
  4. The New Karma System

Forum Announcements

In the past, we've been unable to let everyone know when there's a major bit of system maintenance coming up.  If it was important enough, we'd run around to all the sites and make a front page news posting about it and hoped that people would see it.

Now, we can set a broadcast message that appears at the top of ALL forum pages.  We can set these on a site-by-site basis.

announce1

Clicking on the Read More link will open a message with further details (if available).

Beyond the announcements, you'll notice a bunch of new buttons on forum comments...

newbuttons1

Return to Top Button

Every comment has this little arrow now.  Clicking it will return you to the top of the page.

Report Post

The report post feature returns.  It is limited to logged in users only, and you must provide a detailed reason for the report.  We'll know if you're spamming it, and we will hurt you if you do!

Give Karma

karmalinkThis is a completely new feature for the forums.  In the past, we had the "Insightful" and "Informative" buttons, but in actuality, they didn't do anything (rather, they had once long ago, but not in the last 2+ years).  So with the new forums we decided to add a real karma system.  Now, you can give comments a rating if you found them particularly good or helpful.

Karma Points are shown under your user picture on the left of your posts along with your user number and online status.

See that little number?  You can click on it to see a report on when you received karma, on which posts, and why people gave you the rating.

 

karmarep

As you receive more points, the list will grow.  You'll see your overall stats at the top with score and number of ratings received.

It's important to note that there is no way to rate someone DOWN.  You can only give kudos to folks so it's a 100% positive system.

Here are the limitations on giving karma:

  1. The number of points you can assign is limited by your access level.  Citizens can give +1, Apprentices +2 etc.
  2. You can rate the same person no faster than once every 10 minutes.  Want to give Jafo a +1?  See another post of his you want to give a +1?  You have to wait 10min between ratings.
  3. You must provide a reason for your rating.  It will be recorded on the reporting page.  We also keep track on the back-end who gives what comments so we will find you if you're mean.

The points themselves don't DO anything yet, but there are ideas being kicked around on what we can do with these points.  For now, it's a nice way to recognize people for their contributions on the forums.

 

So those are the major updates for the forums for April.  If you have any questions, let us know!


Comments (Page 4)
5 PagesFirst 2 3 4 5 
on Apr 30, 2008
kwyjibo yes it is true that there is a potential for a clique to form over the Karma points.
Says teh guy with the most karma points around. 
on Apr 30, 2008
Conform and you are rewarded by the popular ones. Break that mould and you are shunned.


Personally I give my Karma to people who I feel add something different, new, and innovative to the mix.

So, no. You're kinda wrong.
on Apr 30, 2008
You say I didn't read the article, but I said nothing about negative ratings, because I did read the article. But you apparently missed this gem: "The points themselves don't DO anything yet, but there are ideas being kicked around on what we can do with these points." I am referring to the potential for a clique to form when inevitable rewards are given for high karma ratings such that only the same people have access to the rewards and access to giving others the rewards. Anyone with a differing opinion will be shut out.


In a forum dedicated to artistic expression, to breaking the mould, a Karma system is counter-productive because it enforces conformity only. Conform and you are rewarded by the popular ones. Break that mould and you are shunned. I fail to see how Art and conformity can coexist.


Wow. You've succeeded only in taking this fun little activity to a stellar level of ridiculous. Why the 'sky is falling' attitude?

IT AINT THAT DEEP
on Apr 30, 2008
Says teh guy with the most karma points around.


Ah Zubaz, have you checked your number?     
on Apr 30, 2008
I tried to give someone karma this morning. It wouldn't let me, saying it was within ten minutes. It was actually within ten hours... 
on Apr 30, 2008
Ah Zubaz, have you checked your number?
Crao.

CrapCrapCrapCrap, 
on Apr 30, 2008
Ah Zubaz, have you checked your number?
Crao.

CrapCrapCrapCrap,


      
on Apr 30, 2008
I tried to give someone karma this morning. It wouldn't let me, saying it was within ten minutes. It was actually within ten hours..


Same here. Guess some bugs still exist. Oh well, it is an adventure!
on Apr 30, 2008

kwyjibo , as far as the Wincustomize site admins are concerned there are only two types of members....those who abide by the site's rules of conduct and those who do not, and the latter are shown the door....in a timely fashion.

The new 'Karma' system has no bearing on that.

What it can represent, however is a public community's reflection on the 'worth' of their input....aka positive, helpful advice, etc.  If, at some future time it's deemed to warrant some form of reward for 'services rendered' then it's much akin to the User Levels already in place.

At this stage it's a 'fun feature' [that Zubaz seems to be cheating in....how the heck do you get Karma when you can't even spell the word the same twice in a row? ... ]  Let's see how it all goes....

 

on Apr 30, 2008
I love it...if it only ever goes this far, stays just this way....what a wonderful way to make someone's day!

I love giving Karma...to people with talent, to people who are funny, insightful, etc.

on Apr 30, 2008
The karma feature seems to be a really nice update to the forums. A very nice way to express your gratitutde towards individuals who make an effort to assist others. Great job guys....  
on Apr 30, 2008
ZubaZ is tempted to give Jafo Karma jsut to make him look bad
on Apr 30, 2008

Zubaz is tempted to give Jafo Karma jsut to make him look bad

Jafo wonders what Zubaz's name really is.....'cos it's bound to be a typo in itself.....

Jafo needs no help to 'look bad' ..... he was born this way....

on Apr 30, 2008
Jafo needs no help to 'look bad'


...ain't that the truth......
on May 01, 2008
I want mine taken away. I reckon the value of Karma is  proportional to the amount of dorkiness...

Fuzzy thinks Zubaz aught to be well ahead by now...
5 PagesFirst 2 3 4 5