From technology to politics to video games; these are the random thoughts of a geek with too much time on his hands
Let us know what you want to see!
Published on May 1, 2007 By Zoomba In OS Customization
WinCustomize 2007 was mostly about building a more robust and stable foundation to handle our ever-increasing traffic and site complexity, with that accomplished we're setting our sights on 2008.  The WinCustomize 2008 project is heavily focused on improving the user experience of submitting, browsing and downloading skins.  We have spent the past several weeks internally picking over what we do and don't like about how the site works, and what we'd like to see improved.  As we work on finalizing features, page layouts and other design elements, I will be making posts like this one seeking community feedback and suggestions.

One area we've decided is in need of some tender, loving care... and a rather serious overhaul... is the upload system.

Our upload page has been largely unchanged for quite a while now.  And while it serves its purpose, it's neither as friendly, nor as robust as many what other sites on the net user to allow users to upload content.  The time has come to spend some time and energy to bring the upload system up to speed with the rest of the site, and with the rest of the web.  We've spent time going over sites like DeviantArt, Customize.org, Flickr, MySpace, Photobucket etc to see how they do things, and what we might like to use over on WinCustomize.  But, at the end of the day we're not the ones who will really "live" with whatever is finally implemented. 

So, before we start the deep dive into designing and developing a new upload process, we want your views and opinions on what you would like to see included in a new upload system.  It can be additional options, it can be technical features on the page such as batch-uploading etc.  We want to know what the artists and regular contributors most want to see in the submission system.


Comments
on May 01, 2007
maybe a way to "credit" others for their input (like a "credits: " [ ]) where you can put in usernames of people you want to credit for help or work, etc. It would then make a link out to their site.

Also, a way to format the description, it would be nice to be able to use LIMITED html bold/underline/bullets, etc.

i like the new uploaded, seems to work.

Any chance of changing that even if your a journeyman you still need "approval" for updates, but not for initial uploads? It doesnt make a lot of sense to me to allow me to upload anything i want, but not be able to make an update to it.

Thats my 0.02
on May 01, 2007
Integration to all the apps that are designed to package data.  Why go to a website when I have the app (like SKS or Iconpackager) open in front of me?  File | Upload to WC, fill out a form.  Bam!  Done.
on May 01, 2007
Any chance of changing that even if your a journeyman you still need "approval" for updates, but not for initial uploads? It doesnt make a lot of sense to me to allow me to upload anything i want, but not be able to make an update to it.

In the past, journeymen would "update" their work by simply hitting the "reset date" check box, in an attempt to keep their skins at the top of the recent skins list.  Requiring moderation for updates pretty much eliminated that method of gaming the system.
on May 01, 2007
In the past, journeymen would "update" their work by simply hitting the "reset date" check box, in an attempt to keep their skins at the top of the recent skins list.


*THAT* sounds like grounds for demotion, not fixing the game.  Social engineering vs. system. 
on May 01, 2007
I agree 100% on demotion... if people have made it this far, and are that lame, they need to go back and start over.

Also, I think that having to "ZIP" everything isnt the best idea. I package some things in self-exe's and some as just the dxpack, or exe so that people dont need to download, unzip, and then run.
on May 01, 2007
Base functionality thru browser: Single-screen, using dropdowns for categories and such. For offline creation, direct upload from the design apps, directly in the format that auto-installs for each app. Maybe even a plugin for Photoshop and compatibles that allows direct upload of images for Wallpapers as well.

That's pretty much my take.

- Drake Steele.
on May 02, 2007
I love the new upload page.
Just maybe a way to add a "invisible" message to the moderator in case of update
on May 02, 2007
I like the upload also. Its better, I think.
on May 02, 2007
I would have added "work on progress" groups for beta testing, etc. It would make creation and aid easier for skinners.
on May 02, 2007

I love the new upload page.
Just maybe a way to add a "invisible" message to the moderator in case of update


I don't upload much, but that sounds like a good idea.
on May 03, 2007
i replied in the wrong spot, sorry zoomba.

I like the new upload system because you can see the upload progress and how many minutes it will take ect.......saves sitting around looking at a screen and wondering and waiting....
on May 03, 2007
is it possible for the system to track "updates"? Ie, each time i edit and upload a new "zip" it would append a .1 to the end of a version #? and the date?


IE:
First Upload 1.0
Edit and upload the zip 1.1 - 5/03/07 12:33 pm
Etc.. So that when i look at something i could see if i missed an update?

and i like the idea of having a field where you can tell the mod what was changed in an update, or send them a note, or even cash. LOL