From technology to politics to video games; these are the random thoughts of a geek with too much time on his hands

For the past few weeks we've been running a little contest, mostly just for fun, for icon artists to come up with a handful of St. Patrick's Day themed icons for the desktop.  The rules were they had to cover the 5 major desktop icons, be submitted to the Misc Icon gallery by March 17th and have a preview image posted to the contest forum thread. 

We ended up with five qualifying entries competing for 3 prizes (1 year WinCustomize subscriptions).

To decide the winners, our moderator team cast their votes on their top 3 favorites.  Additionally, we ran a short poll this week asking for the users to vote on their favorite as well.  Typically, when we run a contest, the views of the moderators and judges vary to some extent from results of public voting.  This time however, the results for both judge voting and public voting were identical.  The top three in both sets were spot-on the same, with the 4th place in user voting being a tie.

Here are the results:

1st Place - Po'Smedley
2nd Place - RPGFX
3rd Place - gh33da

Congrats to all of our winners!

The follow-up poll question is:

Should we run similar mini-contests in the future?

UPDATE: Po'Smedley has decided to give away his winnings from the icon contest!  Check out his thread here  on how you might get the 1 year WC sub (and a bonus premium suite).


Comments (Page 1)
2 Pages1 2 
on Mar 22, 2007
Should we run similar mini-contests in the future?



Contests are good and I think the "Mini" contests are a great idea..
So Yes, you should... LoL
on Mar 22, 2007
yeah congrats all!
He Po' don't take the big head now Ok!
on Mar 22, 2007
Congrats to all the winners (especially the community that gets great icons).

I'd love to see more of these (but I'd like to see them the month previous to the "event").
on Mar 22, 2007
Congratulations to everyone

Should we run similar mini-contests in the future?



Contests are good and I think the "Mini" contests are a great idea..
So Yes, you should...


Agreed

It's My Secret
on Mar 22, 2007
Congrats to all.  They were all great submissions!

 
on Mar 22, 2007
Well done everyone!
on Mar 22, 2007
Thanks everyone.

My subscription is good for 2 years, so I'm offering up my prize.
Check out this thread for details.

WWW Link
on Mar 22, 2007
congrats Po, and all the other submissions! They were all nice work. And thank you WC and community for the second place finish! This was a really cool idea, I think more mini contests would be a great idea. Making these icons actually inspired me to start on my first ever IP! It'll be based on the ones I submitted here, but without the St. Patty's Day theme.

on Mar 22, 2007


Congratulations to everybody that joined. They were all great icons! It's great to do something you enjoy and others recognize you for it.
on Mar 22, 2007
to all


Should we run similar mini-contests in the future?



10000% agreed

on Mar 22, 2007
Contests are great. Mini-Contests are good but need more lead time so we get more entries.
on Mar 22, 2007
^^^ Text is hard to read on old eyes.  Bigger might be better for a font like this. 
on Mar 22, 2007
^^^ Text is hard to read on old eyes. Bigger might be better for a font like this.



on Mar 22, 2007
Congrats everyone!!This was a lot of fun.Everyone did such great work.I look
forward to the next one!  
on Mar 22, 2007
congrats to everyone, you are all to be applauded for your work! and yes more contests......
2 Pages1 2